Florida homeowners are seeing something they have not seen in years: rate decreases. In late October 2026 the Office of Insurance Regulation approved four more homeowners rate cuts averaging about 7%, and Citizens has shrunk to roughly 266,000 policies as private carriers write business again. The catch, for a lot of Southwest Florida homes, is the roof.
The 15-year line
There is no statute that says a roof is too old. What there is, across most private carriers, is an underwriting practice: an asphalt shingle roof older than about 15 years usually needs an inspection before a carrier will write or renew the policy, and many will not write a new policy on an older shingle roof at all. Tile and metal are accepted to greater ages. Every carrier sets its own limits, and the decision is always the carrier’s.
In practical terms: if your shingle roof went on in 2011 or earlier, expect the question at renewal this winter.
What the carrier actually wants
- Age. The installation year, ideally from the county permit record.
- Condition. Photos of the field, edges, flashings, penetrations and any soft decking.
- Remaining life. A professional estimate, in years.
- Wind mitigation. Florida form OIR-B1-1802, which records roof shape, deck attachment, roof-to-wall connection and secondary water barrier. After a replacement, have it done within 30 days of the final inspection.
Replacement cost vs. actual cash value
Carriers have moved toward settling older roofs at actual cash value — the depreciated amount — rather than full replacement cost. Some convert a policy at a set roof age. Your agent can tell you which applies to you and whether a roof endorsement is available. We can tell you what the roof needs.
What we do
A roof age and condition assessment is free. We pull the permit history, inspect and photograph the roof, and give you a written report you can hand to your agent, with a plain recommendation: leave it, repair it, or plan the replacement. If it is a replacement, you get the permit, final inspection, contract, paid invoice and warranty documentation carriers ask for.
Coverage, renewal and premium decisions rest with your insurer. Our job is to make sure your roof is documented properly before anyone makes them. Schedule a free roof age and condition assessment.
First Service CGC, Inc. is a veteran-owned Florida Certified General Contractor (CGC 1521074) and Certified Roofing Contractor (CCC 1330957), serving Marco Island to Bradenton since 1994. Call (239) 652-5784.
